29 results
Premium

New 2026 Indian CHALLENGER ELITE

White Plains, NY
Indian Motorcycle of White Plains
$46,999
Premium

Used 2024 Indian CHALLENGER DARK HORSE WITH POWERBAND AUDIO PACKAGE

Forest Hills, NY
Private seller
$19,750

Used 2025 Indian Motorcycle Challenger Dark Horse

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$25,995
Willing to negotiate

Used 2020 Indian Motorcycle CHALLENGER LIMITED

Vernon, CT
Scranton Powersports
$17,999
Price reduced

New 2026 Indian Motorcycle Challenger® Dark Horse®

Norwich, CT
Street Stuff Inc
$27,499*
$28,999
Price reduced

Used 2024 Indian CHALLENGER LIMITED

Groton, CT
New England Cycle Works Inc
$20,999
$23,999
We Ship
Price reduced

Used 2024 Indian CHALLENGER ELITE W/ABS

Pembroke, NH
National Powersports Distributors
$28,499
$28,999
15 year trusted partner
We Ship

Used 2023 Indian CHALLENGER W/ABS

Coxsackie, NY
National Powersports Distributors - Coxsackie
$18,999

New 2026 Indian Motorcycle Challenger® Dark Horse®

Mineola, NY
MINEOLAMOTO
$26,999

Used 2021 Indian Motorcycle Challenger® Dark Horse®

Mahwah, NJ
Locomotion Powersports
$20,499*
Price reduced

New 2026 Indian Motorcycle Challenger Dark Horse

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$27,499
$28,999

Used 2025 Indian Motorcycle Challenger Limited 108" W/ RIDER ASSIST AND powerband a

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$24,599

Used 2020 Indian Motorcycle CHALLENGER DARK HORSE “WHITE SMOKE”

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$17,495

Used 2025 Indian Motorcycle Challenger 108 " Limited WITH RIDER ASSIST AND Powerban

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$24,599

Used 2025 Indian Motorcycle Challenger Limited 108" WITH RIDER ASSIST AND Powerband

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$24,599

Used 2025 Indian Motorcycle Challenger Limited 108" W/ RIDER ASSIST AND powerband a

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$24,599

Used 2023 Indian Motorcycle Challenger Limited

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$20,995

Used 2025 Indian Motorcycle Challenger Dark Horse 108" W/ rider assist +POWERBAND A

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$25,999

Used 2025 Indian Motorcycle Challenger Limited with 108" + FULL RIDER ASSIST PKG +P

Auburn, MA
Wagner Motorsports International, LLC
$24,599

New 2026 Indian Motorcycle CHALLENGER DARK HORSE

Vernon, CT
Scranton Powersports
$29,749

New 2026 Indian Motorcycle 125th ANNIVERSARY CHALLENGER

Vernon, CT
Scranton Powersports
$41,999
We Ship

Used 2025 Indian CHALLENGER DARK HORSE W/ABS

Pembroke, NH
National Powersports Distributors
$23,999
15 year trusted partner
We Ship

Used 2020 Indian CHALLENGER W/ABS

Coxsackie, NY
National Powersports Distributors - Coxsackie
$16,999
We Ship

Used 2020 Indian CHALLENGER W/ABS

Coxsackie, NY
National Powersports Distributors - Coxsackie
$15,299
We Ship
Newly listed

Used 2021 Indian CHALLENGER W/ABS

Coxsackie, NY
National Powersports Distributors - Coxsackie
$14,499

New 2026 Indian Challenger Dark Horse

White Plains, NY
Indian Motorcycle of White Plains
$28,999

Used 2023 Indian Challenger Dark Horse Icon

White Plains, NY
Indian Motorcycle of White Plains
$23,994

New 2025 Indian Challenger Dark Horse

White Plains, NY
Indian Motorcycle of White Plains
$28,494

New 2023 Indian Challenger RR

White Plains, NY
Indian Motorcycle of White Plains
No price listed

Cycle Trader disclaimer: The information provided for each listing is supplied by the seller and/or other third parties. CycleTrader.com is not responsible for the accuracy of the information. Please refer to the Cycle Trader Terms of Use for further information.

Vehicle photos displayed on this page may be AI-enhanced. AI-generated content isn't always correct, so please contact the seller to verify all details.